National Popular Vote Compact Nears Critical Threshold After Midterm Shifts
Democratic gains in five key states bring the interstate compact to the brink of the 270 electoral votes needed to bypass the Electoral College, though legal and political questions remain.
By Grace Almasi ·

A significant effort to ensure the winner of the national popular vote becomes president may soon reach a pivotal milestone. This development follows substantial Democratic victories in the midterm elections held this month. By next year, Democrats are expected to hold full control of five states that have the capacity to sign the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. This agreement allows participating states to award their presidential electoral votes to the winner of the nationwide popular vote rather than the winner of their individual state contests.
If these five states join the eighteen Democratic-led states already in the compact, along with the District of Columbia, the group will surpass the 270 electoral votes required to activate the agreement. Currently, the compact holds a total of 222 electoral votes. The addition of Arizona, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Nevada, and Wisconsin would contribute 61 more electoral votes. A combination of at least four of these new states would push the total over the necessary threshold. So far, no Republican-led states have joined the compact, and the party remains largely divided on the issue.
Leaders in the incoming Democratic states are beginning to weigh their options. Governors and incoming governors in Pennsylvania and Nevada have indicated they are open to signing the legislation that would bring their states into the agreement. However, other governors have not yet publicly stated their positions. A key question looms over these decisions: whether these states, which are traditionally presidential battlegrounds, are willing to relinquish their significant influence in elections ahead of the 2028 presidential contest.
Some Democratic leaders appear more hesitant on the issue than in the past. For example, Democratic Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs, who previously supported the measure, has not recently commented on whether her state's new Democratic majorities should sign on. Her office did not respond to a request for comment before this article was published. Leaders in each state must also consider whether they wish to be the tipping point for a movement that could fundamentally alter how the United States selects its president.
Beyond political considerations, the compact faces various legal and practical challenges. Some legal scholars have noted that the agreement could conflict with the compact clause in the Constitution. This clause states that no state shall enter into an agreement with another state without the consent of Congress, unless the state is actually invaded or in imminent danger that does not admit of delay.
Norman Miller, a constitutional law professor at Willamette University, highlighted several practical issues with the compact. He argued that it could disrupt a core feature of American presidential elections, which is their decentralized nature. States currently decide individually who can vote and how they vote. Miller suggested that forcing electors from one state to vote according to tallies from another state could create tension. He expressed a preference for a standardized set of rules and a federal election authority to handle tabulation, rather than entrusting a national election to 51 separate election administrators.
John Koza, the chairman of National Popular Vote, countered these concerns. He stated that if the compact functions as intended, a centralized bureaucracy or appointed commission is unnecessary. He explained that current state and federal laws already provide for the issuance of a certified vote count from each state. According to Koza, the process simply involves adding those counts together.
Miller argued that the biggest question is whether such a major reform should be achieved through a constitutional amendment. He believes that while more difficult, a constitutional amendment would be a more thorough process to eliminate the Electoral College and address legal and practical challenges. Opponents of a national popular vote, such as the group Save Our States, argue that the current system prevents regional politics and exacerbates existing divides. They contend that without the Electoral College's incentives, American politics would shift further toward regional concerns.
Patrick Rosenstiel, a senior consultant to the National Popular Vote group, expressed high confidence that the compact will succeed. He referenced Pew polling data showing that 63 percent of American voters want a national popular vote in the 2028 presidential election. Rosenstiel believes the system will force candidates to appeal to a broader portion of the country rather than focusing on a select group of voters in battleground states. He emphasized that the reform would make every voter feel that their vote matters, ensuring that every citizen feels valued when casting a ballot.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






