Dr. Tomasz Kosowski Sentenced to Death for 2023 Attorney Murder
Pinellas judge orders execution after finding premeditation outweighs lack of prior criminal record.
By Renata Mehta ·

A Florida judge handed down a death sentence on Thursday to Dr. Tomasz Kosowski, a plastic surgeon convicted of killing an attorney and dumping the body in an Everglades trash bin. The ruling comes after a jury found Kosowski guilty in September of murdering Steven Cozzi in March 2023. Pinellas Circuit Judge Joseph Bulone determined that the aggravating factors of the crime outweighed any mitigating evidence presented during the sentencing phase.
Prosecutors described a methodical plan that began with a conference call regarding a dispute over medical billing. Kosowski answered the call from a Toyota pickup truck parked outside Cozzi’s office, where he waited with supplies including trash bags, a syringe filled with succinylcholine, and a wagon. Investigators tracked the surgeon’s movements using cellphone records and surveillance video to a remote stretch of the Tamiami Trail west of Miami. Authorities believe Kosowski placed the body in a Dumpster that was later emptied by a garbage truck.
The victim’s remains were never recovered. Trash from that route typically goes to a Collier County landfill, but officials stated the facility routinely compacts its waste, making the search for Cozzi’s body nearly impossible. Investigators did find Cozzi’s blood and DNA in the law office bathroom and in the garage at Kosowski’s home. When police arrested the surgeon, they found $280,000 in cash, masks, duct tape, firearms, a ballistic vest marked “EMS,” law enforcement patches, and a vial of the paralyzing drug.
Kosowski represented himself at trial and offered no defense beyond a closing argument claiming the prosecution failed to prove its case. During sentencing, he declined to present mitigating evidence. However, a court-appointed special counsel pointed to his lack of criminal history and his background as a Dartmouth College medical school graduate who specialized in reconstructive breast surgery. Cozzi’s keys, wallet, and cellphone remained on his desk after he vanished, and his husband never heard from him again.
Judge Bulone acknowledged the mitigating factors but stated that none outweighed the premeditated nature of the killing. The judge noted the crime was committed in a cold and calculating manner without moral or legal justification. “The court concludes that the defendant, under the laws of the State of Florida, has forfeited his right to live,” Bulone said. The public defender’s office has been appointed to represent Kosowski in his appeals.
The case centered on a lengthy legal battle over medical billing between Cozzi and a Dunedin, Florida-based practice that Kosowski had treated. Cozzi represented that practice, and the dispute reportedly involved thousands of dollars in shorted billings and damage to the surgeon’s reputation. The death sentence marks the final stage of the initial proceedings, with the appeals process now underway under the supervision of the state public defender.






