AdvertiseDonate
Corpus ChristiLaredoWashingtonLas VegasBostonDetroitMemphisBaltimore
Hot Newswatch · 710 Buffalo Street, Corpus Christi, TX 78401

Grading the NFL's rookie contract quarterbacks as the 2026 season unfolds

A comprehensive evaluation of 12 NFL quarterbacks on rookie contracts highlights the stark contrast between emerging stars like Drake Maye and Caleb Williams and players still proving their worth.

By Renata Mehta ·

Illustration for: Grading the NFL's rookie contract quarterbacks as the 2026 season unfolds
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The NFL currently places a high premium on rosters that feature elite quarterbacks still on their rookie deals. This financial advantage allows teams to allocate cap space to other star players, a strategy that helped the New England Patriots reach the Super Bowl last year and is now propelling the Chicago Bears toward a similar goal in 2026. However, the value of these contracts depends entirely on the player's performance. Standouts like Drake Maye and Caleb Williams are building cases for massive extensions, while underperformers face the difficult prospect of being replaced through the draft.

Drake Maye of the Patriots received an A- grade for his impact, despite a recent ankle injury that may end his season. In his second year, Maye came within one first-place vote of the MVP award and reached the Super Bowl. Although he has struggled with turnovers and a .500 record in 2026, his proven upside remains the highest among any quarterback on a rookie contract. The Patriots view him as the definitive starter for their future.

C.J. Stroud of the Texans earned a B+ as he returns to the form that made him the 2023 Offensive Rookie of the Year. His current statistics, including 273.6 passing yards per game and a 0.9 percent interception rate, mirror his rookie season benchmarks. Houston is expected to sign him to a lucrative extension, betting that his current performance is more indicative of his long-term potential than his inconsistent years in 2024 and 2025.

Bo Nix of the Broncos was graded a B for his continued ability to deliver in critical moments. He leads the league in fourth-quarter comebacks and game-winning drives in 2026, following a similar streak in 2025. While his efficiency metrics have dipped slightly this season, his recent performances suggest he is rounding into form. Denver remains confident in his potential to lead the team to deep playoff runs.

J.J. McCarthy of the Giants received a D+ grade, reflecting a mixed evaluation of his career trajectory. After being traded from the Vikings, McCarthy has shown marked improvement in New York, including a 243-yard fourth quarter in his debut. He has completed 66.3 percent of his passes for 224 yards per game. While his long-term role is uncertain with Jaxson Dart returning next year, his current performance has helped the Giants maintain their divisional lead.

Caleb Williams of the Bears was also graded a B+ as he enters a breakout season. His career-best passer rating and 257.7 passing yards per game have driven Chicago's surge in the Super Bowl race. Despite a four-interception game last week, Williams is showing increased comfort in the offense and is on a trajectory that could eventually lead to MVP consideration.

Bryce Young of the Panthers earned a C+ for his best career year, averaging 266.3 yards per game. His development has been steady under coach Dave Canales, and he now faces a pivotal offseason decision regarding his fifth-year option. The Panthers see him as a quarterback around whom they can continue to build, despite some inconsistent stretches earlier in the season.

Other quarterbacks on rookie deals received varied evaluations. Jayden Daniels of the Commanders was graded a B+ for his elite rushing and improving passing, though injuries have limited his recent impact. Tyler Shough of the Saints and Michael Penix Jr. of the Falcons both earned C grades, with Shough managing a heavy workload and Penix showing flashes of his first-round potential. Cam Ward of the Titans received a D, as the team debates whether to draft a new starter or continue developing the second-year player.

Two quarterbacks were marked as incomplete in their evaluations. Fernando Mendoza of the Raiders is still finding his footing in his debut, while Carson Beck of the Cardinals is working to recover from a UCL injury. Both teams are assessing their long-term options as they navigate the second half of the season and prepare for the upcoming draft.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Hot Newswatch in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Hot Newswatch in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.