AdvertiseDonate
Corpus ChristiLaredoWashingtonLas VegasBostonDetroitMemphisBaltimore
Hot Newswatch · 710 Buffalo Street, Corpus Christi, TX 78401

MPs call for new online safety laws after Google refuses to remove Russell Brand's prison video

Labour MP Jess Phillips argues that existing regulations are insufficient to handle convicted criminals using social media from prison, citing the recent dispute over Russell Brand's YouTube message.

By Grace Almasi ·

Illustration for: MPs call for new online safety laws after Google refuses to remove Russell Brand's prison video
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A new online safety act may be required to address the issue of convicted criminals using social media platforms to communicate directly from prison, according to Labour MP Jess Phillips. The call for stronger legislation follows a dispute involving Russell Brand, who was recently convicted of sexual offences by a jury.

Shortly after his conviction, Brand’s wife, Laura, uploaded a video to their YouTube channel, which has 6.6 million subscribers. In the clip, Brand claims he is not guilty of the crimes for which he was found liable. The message has since attracted nearly 850,000 views, sparking debate about the role of social media in the criminal justice process.

The Ministry of Justice launched an investigation to determine whether Brand violated prison rules by broadcasting the message. Google, the owner of YouTube, has declined a request from the UK government, made through the Prison Service, to take down the video. The government had warned that the content was causing significant distress to survivors of sexual abuse.

A spokesperson for Google stated that the company is aware of the content and that its teams are investigating the matter. The spokesperson noted that Brand’s channel was suspended from the YouTube partner program in September 2023, meaning it has not been able to monetize content since that time. However, the refusal to remove the specific video has drawn criticism from political figures and advocacy groups.

Jess Phillips, a former minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, acknowledged that the government currently lacks the legal power to compel platforms to remove such distressing content. Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, she described the current Ofcom codes on women’s safety online as voluntary, arguing that relying on voluntary codes for tech companies represents the triumph of hope over experience.

Phillips highlighted that the Online Safety Act, passed in 2023, primarily focuses on protecting users from illegal content and ensuring age-appropriate content for under-18s. While the act has been phased in and expanded with additional legislation this year, it does not explicitly cover prisoners using social media to communicate with the outside world. Phillips conceded that the current framework is not sufficient given Brand’s massive online following.

She suggested that regulatory frameworks need to change and that a second online safety act is likely necessary. Phillips argued that before this incident, few prisoners had such significant YouTube followings. She stated that pressure will continue to build on organizations like Google, noting that by leaving the video up, the company demonstrates that existing codes are not robust enough.

Other political figures have weighed in on the matter. Josh MacAlister, the minister for children and families, expressed hope that Google would follow the lead of Meta, the parent company of Facebook. Meta had previously disabled Brand’s social media accounts, citing that they breached standards prohibiting accounts that are harmful to the community. MacAlister noted that this move by Meta set a precedent for action.

Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, described the video as disturbing and the message as abhorrent. He emphasized that while prisoners are generally banned from making statements to the media, this case is exceptional. Pennycook said he hoped Google would comply with the request from MoJ ministers to remove the specific content, particularly given the impact on victims.

Kemi Badenoch, the Conservative leader, offered a differing perspective. She expressed concern about prisoners using conduits in prison to send messages but noted that Brand’s wife was a separate person and that YouTube is a private platform. Badenoch suggested that immediately demanding private platforms take down content without first determining if a law has been broken is not the correct starting point. The Brand case has brought broader concerns to the forefront, including the continued social media presence of other figures such as far-right activist Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, known as Tommy Robinson.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Hot Newswatch in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Hot Newswatch in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.