Slotkin calls DOJ speech probe baseless in letter to Texas U.S. Attorney
The Michigan Democrat argues that a public threat of prosecution over her remarks violates First Amendment protections and departmental policy.
By Amit Chukwu ·

Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan told a Trump-appointed Justice Department official on Wednesday that his proposed investigation into her political speech is baseless and should be withdrawn immediately.
Slotkin, a Democrat, is one of five members of Congress who received letters from Aaron Reitz, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas. Reitz posted these letters on social media, suggesting that Slotkin’s comments about congressional oversight could constitute a criminal civil rights offense.
In her letter, Slotkin stated that she made the comments in accordance with her First Amendment right to freedom of speech. She argued that as a United States Senator, oversight is a constitutional responsibility protected by the Speech or Debate clause. That clause bars the prosecution of a legislator for performing legislative acts.
The senator criticized Reitz for publicly posting the letter instead of sending it to her, her attorney, or Senate legal counsel. Slotkin described the public nature of the threat as evidence that the inquiry is driven by publicity and political ambition rather than legal merit.
Slotkin accused Reitz of violating Justice Department policy with his public threats. She said his actions suggest he is either seeking attention for himself and the department or unaware of basic constitutional rights.
Reitz, 39, previously served as chief of staff for Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas. He assumed the role of U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas over the summer after finishing fourth in the Republican primary for Texas attorney general.
The U.S. Attorney also posted similar letters to Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts, Sen. Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut, Rep. Robert Garcia of California, and Sen. Adam Schiff of California. In a separate interview, Reitz told NBC News that he was not interested in chilling free speech.
Earlier this year, the Trump administration targeted Slotkin and five other Democratic lawmakers over a social media video. The video advised members of the military and intelligence communities not to obey unlawful orders. Allies of U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro of the District of Columbia attempted to indict the six Democrats for that speech, but federal grand jurors unanimously rejected the indictment.
Attorney General Todd Blanche conceded last week that Slotkin’s words alone were absolutely not a crime. He stated at a press conference that there were no ongoing criminal investigations into words spoken by incoming senators or congressmen.
Slotkin’s attorney, Prett Bharara, had previously written to Blanche cautioning him against following President Donald Trump’s instruction to investigate Slotkin’s speech. Trump had called the speech a criminal act. Slotkin concluded her letter by reserving all rights to take appropriate actions in the future regarding what she called a sham investigation.






