AdvertiseDonate
Corpus ChristiLaredoWashingtonLas VegasBostonDetroitMemphisBaltimore
Hot Newswatch · 710 Buffalo Street, Corpus Christi, TX 78401

Week 12 College Football: Playoff Expansion Debates and Rising Stars

As college football enters Week 12, debates over playoff expansion intensify while standout players like Jeremiah Smith and Darian Mensah drive the season's narrative.

By Renata Mehta ·

Illustration for: Week 12 College Football: Playoff Expansion Debates and Rising Stars
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

College football fans face a divided perspective on the 2026 season as the league considers expanding the College Football Playoff to 24 teams. From one angle, the current landscape lacks true championship contenders, with only 24 teams meeting a high standard of having three or fewer losses. This number is lower than in any previous year of the playoff era and ten fewer than last season. If the criteria are tightened further to include only teams with at least one win against a top 25 opponent, the count drops to just 13.

However, proponents of expansion argue that while the field may lack elite contenders, it would increase the stakes for late-season games. Currently, Week 12 features matchups that appear routine, such as Miami hosting Virginia Tech or a Division II game on Fox. Under a 24-team format, these games would carry significant weight in the battle for the final playoff spots, transforming perceived non-events into critical contests.

Specific examples illustrate this shift. SMU’s upcoming road game against Notre Dame is currently viewed as low-stakes, but a victory would create a compelling case for a playoff berth. Similarly, the Kentucky-Missouri matchup, often seen as a struggle for both teams, would become a decisive showdown where the winner gains a strong position for a home playoff game. The LSU-Tennessee game, currently watched with skepticism due to Lane Kiffin’s struggles, would also take on greater importance in an expanded field.

Beyond the structural debate, individual performances are shaping the season’s narrative. Jeremiah Smith of Iowa has emerged as a standout player, setting a Big Ten record with his 17th 100-yard game. In the past decade, all Iowa players combined have only 16 such games. Smith leads the nation with 25 contested catches, a margin of seven more than the next closest Power 4 player. His consistency is evident in the 58 catches that resulted in a first down or touchdown, a number 13 higher than any other receiver in the conference.

At Miami, quarterback Darian Mensah has thrived despite the absence of his top receiver, Malachi Toney. In recent games against Notre Dame and Duke, Mensah has thrown for 686 yards, four touchdowns, and just one interception. His performance suggests that his Heisman candidacy remains strong regardless of Toney’s injury status. This week, he faces a Virginia Tech defense that has allowed significant passing production recently, ranking poorly in opponent passer rating and yards per pass allowed.

Other notable storylines include Nebraska’s ongoing struggle against ranked opponents, having lost 31 consecutive games to such foes. The Huskers will need to contain Smith to break this streak. Meanwhile, UCLA and Michigan prepare for a defensive battle, with UCLA holding the second-best success rate against FBS opponents while Michigan ranks fourth in explosive play rate. The outcome of this game could influence perceptions of both programs’ defensive prowess.

The Heisman Trophy race remains tight, with Jeremiah Smith, Darian Mensah, Gunner Stockton, Devon Dampier, and CJ Carr leading the conversation. However, some analysts argue that players like Utah offensive lineman Zereoue Williams deserve more recognition. Williams has allowed only two pressures and no sacks all season, contributing significantly to Utah’s undefeated record. His dominance on the offensive line highlights the importance of positional excellence beyond the traditional skill positions.

As the season moves toward its final stretch, the debate over playoff expansion continues to influence how teams and fans view each game. Whether the 24-team format dilutes the prestige of a playoff spot or enhances the drama of the regular season remains a matter of perspective. What is clear is that the current slate of games offers a mix of high-stakes contests and intriguing individual stories that keep the sport engaging.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Hot Newswatch in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Hot Newswatch in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.