Colts Stick With Daniel Jones Despite Poor Performance Over Anthony Richardson
Indianapolis head coach Shane Steichen continues to start Daniel Jones, who is currently the NFL's worst starter, while backup Anthony Richardson struggles to earn a starting role despite his talent.
By Amit Chukwu ·

The Indianapolis Colts face a puzzling quarterback situation as they prepare for their upcoming game against the Houston Texans. Despite starting quarterback Daniel Jones posting the worst metrics in the league this season, head coach Shane Steichen remains committed to keeping him under center. This decision has raised questions about the team's strategy, particularly given the presence of backup Anthony Richardson, who has shown flashes of brilliance during practice.
Jones is currently ranked as the worst starting quarterback in the NFL in several key categories. He has the lowest QBR at 30.3 and averages only 5.6 yards per attempt. Additionally, he leads the league with 12 interceptions. In his most recent game against the Miami Dolphins, Jones recorded a QBR of 1.7, the lowest for any starter in 2026. He has not thrown for more than 200 yards in any of his last four games, a stretch that marks a significant downturn in his career.
Steichen defends his choice by citing the complexity of evaluating a quarterback. He stated that he reviews game film extensively to determine if mistakes are attributable to the quarterback or other players. The coach emphasized that protecting the football is a primary concern, a task Jones has struggled with, as he has committed 13 fumbles and has a touchdown to interception ratio of 7 to 12 in his 23 games as a starter.
The Colts' offense has been weakened by recent trades, including the departure of receivers Josh Downs and Keenan Allen, as well as All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson. Despite these changes, Jones' performance was already under scrutiny before the roster moves. The team fired general manager Chris Ballard in October and has lost five of their last six games, currently sitting four games behind the division-leading Jacksonville Jaguars.
Richardson, the number four overall pick in the 2023 draft, was initially expected to be the cornerstone of the offense under Steichen. The coach had previously developed young quarterbacks like Justin Herbert and Jalen Hurts. Richardson was named the Week 1 starter in his rookie year after a brief preseason appearance. However, his tenure has been marked by inconsistency and injuries, leading to a mid-season benching in 2024 following a controversial play.
Although Richardson returned to the lineup later in 2024 and had some game-winning drives, his career passing efficiency stands at 50.9 percent. This inconsistency, combined with physical issues, led the organization to sign Jones the following spring. Jones has since secured a two-year, $88 million contract extension, which may influence the coach's decision to stick with him.
Richardson's electric running ability remains a notable asset, with 10 rushing touchdowns in 15 career starts. Steichen has acknowledged that this explosive playmaking could provide a spark for the offense. Teammates have also praised his speed, with defensive end Jaylahn Tuimoloau describing him as exceptionally explosive during scout team reps.
Despite the potential, Richardson has yet to receive a starting opportunity in 2026. He requested a trade earlier in the year, a move that highlighted his uncertain status with the franchise. With Ballard, his former ally, no longer in charge, Richardson is navigating a difficult position. He recently faced a citation for marijuana possession and may face a suspension, though this has not directly impacted his current lineup status.
Richardson maintains that he continues to prepare as if he were the starter, ready for his number to be called. However, as the season progresses, it remains unclear when or if that opportunity will materialize under Steichen's leadership.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






