Montana’s TikTok ban raises legal and technical questions

Montana Gov. Greg Gianforte on Wednesday signed into regulation a first-of-its variety invoice that makes it unlawful for TikTok to function within the state, establishing a possible authorized battle with the corporate amid a litany of questions over whether or not the state may even implement the regulation.

The brand new guidelines in Montana could have extra far-reaching results than TikTok bans already in place on government-issued gadgets in almost half the states and the U.S. federal authorities. There are 200,000 TikTok customers in Montana in addition to 6,000 companies that use the video-sharing platform, in response to firm spokesperson Jamal Brown.

Right here’s what it’s essential to know:


Proponents of the regulation in Montana declare the Chinese language authorities might harvest U.S. consumer knowledge from TikTok and use the platform to push pro-Beijing misinformation or messages to the general public.

That mirrors arguments made by a bipartisan group of lawmakers within the U.S. Senate, in addition to the heads of the FBI and the CIA, all of whom have stated TikTok might pose a nationwide safety menace as a result of its Beijing-based guardian firm ByteDance operates below Chinese language regulation.

Critics have pointed to China’s 2017 nationwide intelligence regulation that compels corporations to cooperate with the nation’s governments for state intelligence work. One other Chinese language regulation, applied in 2014, has related mandates.

TikTok says it has by no means been requested at hand over its knowledge, and it wouldn’t accomplish that if requested.


The regulation will prohibit downloads of TikTok within the state and positive any “entity” — an app retailer or TikTok — $10,000 per day for every time somebody accesses TikTok, “is obtainable the flexibility” to entry it, or downloads it.

Meaning Apple and Google, which function app shops on Apple and Android gadgets, can be responsible for any violations. Penalties wouldn’t apply to customers.

The statewide ban gained’t take impact till January 2024. It might be void if the social media platform is bought to an organization that’s not based mostly in “any nation designated as a overseas adversary” by the federal authorities.

The governor indicated he needs to broaden the invoice to different social media apps in an effort to deal with among the invoice’s “technical and authorized issues.” However the legislature adjourned earlier than sending him the invoice, which meant he couldn’t provide his amendments.

Montana Legal professional Normal Austin Knudsen has pointed to know-how used to limit on-line sports activities playing apps as a option to curtail TikTok from working within the state. These violations could be reported by anybody. And as soon as the state verifies a breach has taken place, it sends a cease-and-desist letter to the corporate concerned, stated Kyler Nerison, a spokesperson for Knudsen’s workplace. He stated completely different corporations use completely different strategies for compliance and it’s as much as them “to not permit their apps to work in Montana and different states the place they don’t seem to be authorized.”


Cybersecurity consultants say that, aside from avoiding the positive, there’s nothing incentivizing the businesses concerned to conform and will probably be extraordinarily troublesome — if not unattainable — to adequately implement the regulation.

For one, the U.S. doesn’t have something equal to the kind of management international locations like China have on what their residents entry on the internet. Compounding that, web service suppliers are out of the image.

Earlier than the Montana regulation handed, lawmakers rewrote parts of the invoice to allow them to off the hook after a lobbyist for AT&T stated throughout a February listening to the laws was “not workable” to put in force.


Apple and Google haven’t spoken out in opposition to the regulation. However a consultant for TechNet, the commerce group that counts the 2 tech giants as its members, has stated app shops don’t have the flexibility to “geofence” apps in numerous states and it will be unattainable to stop TikTok from being downloaded in Montana. The group has additionally stated the duty must be on an app to find out the place it could possibly function, not an app retailer.

Telecoms analyst Roger Entner, of Recon Analytics, says he believes the app shops might have the aptitude to implement the regulation, however it will be cumbersome to implement and stuffed with loopholes. Apple and Google’s address-linked billing could possibly be bypassed with pay as you go playing cards and IP geolocation simply masked by utilizing a VPN service, which might alter IP addresses and permits customers to evade content material restrictions, stated cell safety skilled Will Strafach, the founding father of Guardian, which makes a privateness safety app for Apple gadgets.

Oded Vanunu, head of merchandise vulnerability analysis on the cybersecurity agency Examine Level, agreed it will be troublesome for app shops to isolate a single state from downloading an app. He instructed it will be extra possible for TikTok to conform because it controls the software program and might “modify the settings based mostly on the geographical location or IP addresses” of customers.


When customers permit TikTok to gather their location data, it could possibly monitor an individual to no less than 3 sq. kilometers (1.16 sq. miles) from their precise location. If that characteristic is disabled, TikTok can nonetheless accumulate approximate location data – such because the area, metropolis or zip code through which a consumer could also be situated – based mostly on system or community data, like an IP deal with.

However much like the app shops, cybersecurity consultants observe that any enforcement measures the corporate implements could possibly be simply bypassed with a VPN and efforts to make use of IP geolocating would possibly result in different points.

David Choffnes, the chief director of the Cybersecurity and Privateness Institute at Northeastern College, stated cell suppliers might use the identical sorts of IP addresses for a number of states, which might imply somebody who is just not in Montana might incorrectly be blocked from utilizing TikTok.


Doubtless a authorized battle.

Knudsen, Montana’s lawyer normal, has already stated he expects the regulation will find yourself in courtroom.

TikTok spokesperson Brooke Oberwetter stated in a ready assertion Wednesday that the regulation infringes on Montanan’s free speech rights and is illegal.

“We wish to reassure Montanans that they will proceed utilizing TikTok to precise themselves, earn a dwelling, and discover neighborhood as we proceed working to defend the rights of our customers inside and outdoors of Montana,” Oberwetter stated.

Oberwetter declined to say if the corporate will file a lawsuit however described among the authorized points at play. She argued Montana is making an attempt to override U.S. overseas coverage by claiming the invoice addresses a nationwide safety danger. She stated overseas coverage and nationwide safety legal guidelines usually are not made on the state degree.

NetChoice, a commerce group that represents TikTok and different tech corporations, says the invoice would violate the First Modification and “invoice of attainder” legal guidelines that prohibit the federal government from imposing a punishment on a selected entity and not using a formal trial.

Back To Top