Cornyn Withholds Support for Trump's Texas Court Nominee Over State Residency
Senate Majority Leader John Cornyn blocked the confirmation of T. Elliot Gaiser for a federal judgeship in Texas, citing the candidate's lack of residency and trial experience.
By Renata Mehta ·

Outgoing Senator John Cornyn of Texas withheld his support on Wednesday for President Donald Trump's nominee, T. Elliot Gaiser, to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. The primary reason for the block was that Gaiser is not a resident of Texas. Cornyn, who is scheduled to be succeeded by Democratic Senator-elect James Talarico, declined to submit a blue slip for the candidate. This slip is part of a longstanding Senate Judiciary Committee tradition that allows home-state senators to evaluate judicial nominees. When a blue slip is withheld or returned with a negative assessment, the confirmation process typically stalls.
According to an aide, Cornyn had been urging the White House for several months to recommend Steve Fahey, a former federal prosecutor, for the vacant seat instead. The senator accused the administration of completely ignoring his requests. Cornyn stated that he was unwilling to allow the White House to disregard the Senate's constitutional role in the appointment process.
Gaiser was originally scheduled to testify before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday. However, he was not included among the seven federal judicial candidates who appeared for confirmation hearings. In a statement to CNN, Cornyn said he refused to be forced into accepting a non-Texan candidate who lacked trial experience and had not undergone proper vetting. He noted that he had provided the White House with an alternative candidate and hoped they would accept it to prevent the seat from remaining vacant.
In comments to CBS News, Cornyn declared that Gaiser's nomination was no longer viable. He emphasized that the nominee was not from Texas and had no background in trial work. The senator criticized the White House for attempting to push the nomination through the Senate without allowing for adequate due diligence on what he described as lifetime appointments.
The White House was contacted for comment regarding the development. Before his nomination, Gaiser lived in Ohio. He was previously selected to lead the Office of Legal Counsel at the Department of Justice. President Trump formally sent Gaiser's nomination to the Senate on Monday.
Gaiser has been in the news recently for issuing a classified legal opinion that justified lethal strikes against drug cartels and suspected traffickers. CNN reported last month that Gaiser argued these actions did not trigger the war powers law because they did not meet the specific definition of hostilities. Additionally, in August, the Ohio resident ruled that Trump's outside advisers are protected from future congressional and legal investigations, with their internal communications shielded by executive privilege.
This dispute is part of a broader pattern among lame-duck Republican lawmakers who are signaling that other judicial nominees may face similar obstacles. For instance, Trump's choice for the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma, attorney Zach West, is facing resistance. Senator Alan Armstrong of Oklahoma withdrew his support for West. Meanwhile, Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina indicated he might maintain his opposition to the nomination.
Tillis described the situation as an unforced error by the White House for not consulting more effectively with Senator Armstrong. He expressed a belief that the nomination would ultimately be resolved but warned that the process was being run down to the final moments of the legislative session.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






