AdvertiseDonate
Corpus ChristiLaredoWashingtonLas VegasBostonDetroitMemphisBaltimore
Hot Newswatch · 710 Buffalo Street, Corpus Christi, TX 78401

First 2027 Fantasy Baseball Mock Draft Reveals Little Consensus in Round 1

The first mock draft of the 2027 fantasy baseball season showed wide disagreement at the top, with Shohei Ohtani, Pete Crow-Armstrong and Aaron Judge leading a first round full of surprises.

By Amit Chukwu ·

Illustration for: First 2027 Fantasy Baseball Mock Draft Reveals Little Consensus in Round 1
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

With the World Series in the rearview mirror and offseason roster moves underway, a group of 12 fantasy analysts has completed what CBS Sports writer Scott White described as the first mock draft of the 2027 season. The exercise, built for Rotisserie leagues using traditional 5x5 scoring and 23-man lineups, offered an early look at a player pool that remains unsettled, with a lockout of uncertain length potentially looming over the sport.

The clearest takeaway, according to White, is the lack of agreement at the top. Pete Crow-Armstrong has emerged as the early consensus choice for the top pick, particularly in this format, but White said he still leans toward Shohei Ohtani, provided Ohtani enters spring training with a clean bill of health. Ohtani was hampered for much of 2026 and fell short of his customary .300 average, 50 home runs and 20 stolen bases, yet White argued that a return to that standard is a smaller ask than Crow-Armstrong repeating his 2026 performance.

The draft board reflected that divide. Ohtani, Crow-Armstrong and Aaron Judge came off the board with the first three selections, even though early NFBC average draft position data ranks them second, first and ninth. White, who holds the same top three in his own rankings, said the spread shows how much room there is for disagreement this year, likely because so many established stars underperformed in 2026.

Among the surprises: James Wood was not selected in the first round at all, instead opening Round 2 as the pick of Sean Martin of Fantasy Baseball Now. White said a top-six case exists for Wood, who was producing on par with Crow-Armstrong before straining his oblique in August. Elsewhere in Round 1, Yordan Alvarez went at Pick 9 despite an ADP of 12th and a No. 4 ranking from White, while Junior Caminero, the sixth-highest-rated player selected, fell to Frank Stampfl of CBS Sports at Pick 10.

By Round 2, White said, the pool of players worthy of first-round consideration had clearly thinned. That is where the biggest disappointments of 2026, a group featuring Ronald Acuna, Jose Ramirez, Corbin Carroll and Julio Rodriguez, began to come off the board. Taking any of them earlier, he argued, would not be defensible regardless of their upside or track record.

White, picking second, saw Rodriguez go one selection before his Round 2 turn. With no clear statistical standout left at Pick 23, he leaned fully into position scarcity and took second baseman Brice Turang, confident he could wait on third base with Miguel Vargas and Sal Stewart still available. He landed Vargas in Round 3, but said that finishing with four third base-eligible players, including Zack Gelof, Isaac Paredes and Austin Riley, has him rethinking the conventional belief that the position is thin.

White also broke from his usual tendencies by using five of his first nine picks on pitchers, among them closers Josh Hader and Aroldis Chapman. With only about 15 established closers currently in place, he said many drafters were forced into speculative saves bets such as Raisel Iglesias in Round 8, Robert Suarez in Round 17, Adrian Morejon in Round 20, Jeff Hoffman in Round 21, Justin Martinez in Round 22 and Felix Bautista in Round 23.

Despite the heavy pitching investment, White said he believes his hitting is his team's strength. Filling the scarce infield spots early freed him to chase value later, and he singled out Jake McCarthy in Round 8 and Freddie Freeman in Round 11 as mid-round boosts to a batting average he had neglected early on.

White cautioned that player values remain a work in progress, listing Tanner Bibee at 117th overall, Colson Montgomery at 132, Josh Naylor at 137, Framber Valdez at 145, Royce Lewis at 179, Christian Scott at 197 and Ryan Pepiot at 213 as picks that came far earlier than his rankings justify. Whether the broader market agrees, he said, will become clearer as draft season unfolds.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Hot Newswatch in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Hot Newswatch in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.