Federal Judge Keeps Man Shot by ICE Agents in New York Custody
A U.S. District Court judge ruled that a procedural error in an arrest warrant did not require the release of a Dominican national who was wounded by immigration officers last month.
By Renata Mehta ·

A federal judge in New York has denied a motion to release a man who was shot and wounded by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents during his arrest last month. The decision, issued by U.S. District Court Judge Hector Gonzalez on Friday, keeps the detainee in federal custody while his deportation proceedings continue.
In a written ruling, Judge Gonzalez acknowledged that immigration officers may have committed a procedural error when serving the arrest warrant on Oscar Belgal. The agents served the warrant before providing Belgal with the required notice to appear in immigration court. However, the judge characterized this oversight as a technical error that does not necessitate his immediate release from custody.
Belgal, a 28-year-old national of the Dominican Republic, first entered the United States illegally in 2021. Two years later, he was arrested on robbery and other charges, eventually pleading guilty to grand larceny and receiving a sentence of probation. In 2025, he faced a new arrest on allegations of attempting to sell controlled substances, a case that remains pending in the courts.
The incident in question occurred on October 8, during a period of intensified immigration enforcement under President Donald Trump. According to security camera footage released by New York City police, a plainclothes officer ran toward Belgal as he drove his five-year-old son home from school. The officer pointed a gun at the driver and then used the barrel of the weapon to shatter the driver's side window. A second officer also drew his weapon as Belgal attempted to drive away. The short chase ended when Belgal's car, which sustained multiple bullet impacts, came to a stop.
Belgal was struck in the shoulder and neck, while his son was unharmed. His legal team stated that he did not realize the men were ICE officers until he regained consciousness in a hospital. In a written statement, The Legal Aid Society, a nonprofit law firm representing Belgal, called it unconscionable that he must spend another day in detention separated from his family after enduring such suffering.
Federal officials defended the actions of the agents, stating they fired their weapons because they believed their lives were in danger. They noted that Belgal had smashed his car into two government vehicles and accelerated toward other officers. Conversely, Belgal's attorneys argued that the agents lacked a valid warrant and failed to identify themselves before approaching the vehicle. They contended that his due process rights were violated by an unreasonable use of extreme force.
Judge Gonzalez disagreed with the argument that the agents did not possess a valid warrant. He further ruled that the petition for release was not the appropriate legal venue to argue that excessive force was used during the arrest. The judge noted that Belgal retains the option to request release on bond from the immigration court in the future.
The ruling was reported from Seattle, with contributions from Associated Press writer Michael R. Sisak in New York.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






