Federal judge keeps shot immigration detainee in custody despite procedural errors
A New York federal judge ruled that Oscar Belgal, who was wounded by ICE agents during an arrest in October, must remain in federal custody while deportation proceedings continue.
By Amit Chukwu ·

A federal judge in New York declined on Friday to release Oscar Belgal, a 28-year-old Dominican national who was shot and wounded by immigration officers during an arrest in October. Judge Hector Gonzalez of the US district court issued a written ruling that acknowledged potential procedural mistakes made by the agents but determined that these errors did not warrant Belgal's immediate release from federal custody.
According to the ruling, the officers may have committed a technical error by serving an arrest warrant on Belgal before providing him with a notice to appear in immigration court. However, Gonzalez wrote that this oversight was not significant enough to require the detainee's release while his deportation cases are pending.
Belgal entered the United States illegally in 2021. Approximately two years later, he was arrested on robbery and other charges, eventually pleading guilty to grand larceny and receiving a probation sentence. In 2025, he was arrested again on allegations of attempting to sell controlled substances, a case that remains unresolved.
The incident in question occurred on October 8, during an ongoing immigration enforcement operation by the Trump administration. US Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents located Belgal while he was driving his five-year-old son home from school. Security camera footage released by the New York City police depicts a plainclothes officer running toward the vehicle with a gun drawn, using the barrel of his weapon to break the driver's side window. A second officer then drew his weapon as Belgal drove away, leading to a brief chase that ended when the car came to a stop after being struck by multiple bullets.
Belgal sustained injuries to his shoulder and neck, while his young son was unharmed. His legal team stated that the detainee did not realize the men were ICE officers until he regained consciousness in a hospital bed. Federal officials defended the use of force, claiming the agents fired because they believed their lives were in danger after Belgal allegedly smashed his car into two government vehicles and accelerated toward other officers.
Belgal's attorneys argued that the agents lacked a valid warrant and failed to identify themselves before approaching the car, breaking a window, and firing several shots inside. They contended that his due process rights were violated by the use of extreme and unreasonable force during the arrest. In a written statement, the Legal Aid Society, the non-profit firm representing Belgal, called it unconscionable that he should spend another day in detention separated from his family after enduring such suffering.
Judge Gonzalez disagreed with the argument that the agents lacked a valid warrant. He further noted that the petition for release was not the appropriate legal venue to argue that excessive force was used. The judge indicated that Belgal retains the option to request release on bond through the immigration court.






