AdvertiseDonate
Corpus ChristiLaredoWashingtonLas VegasBostonDetroitMemphisBaltimore
Hot Newswatch · 710 Buffalo Street, Corpus Christi, TX 78401

Experts warn Social Security faces insolvency crisis due to decades of legislative inaction

Economists and lawmakers argue that a 1977 decision to tie benefits to wages created a solvency problem that Congress has largely ignored until now.

By Grace Almasi ·

Illustration for: Experts warn Social Security faces insolvency crisis due to decades of legislative inaction
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A panel of distinguished economists, which included a Nobel Peace Prize winner, issued a warning to Congress decades ago regarding reforms to the Social Security program. That group predicted that specific policy choices would lead to long-term financial instability. Experts now state that the original warning was accurate as the program moves toward a crisis that could impact millions of Americans.

Andrew Biggs, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, noted that Social Security benefits have been on autopilot since 1977. He said that since that time, Congress has done as little as possible to address the program's structural issues. The current debate centers on a report released by Senate Budget Committee Chair Ron Johnson, a Republican from Wisconsin. Johnson described the decades-old program as a Ponzi scheme and argued that the slide into insolvency began in the 1970s.

During that era, lawmakers chose to tie benefit growth to wages rather than inflation despite warnings from an expert panel. Johnson wrote that the panel advised lawmakers that linking benefits to inflation would likely have kept Social Security sustainable today. Instead, lawmakers passed amendments that were signed into law by former President Jimmy Carter in December 1977. Biggs explained that indexing benefit growth to wages effectively built a solvency crisis into the program by over-promising benefits that the system could not afford.

Romina Boccia, the director of budget and entitlement policy at the Cato Institute, agreed with Johnson's characterization of the system as a Ponzi scheme. She stated that many Americans mistakenly believe Social Security is a retirement savings program. Boccia clarified that a true savings program requires assets to be invested to earn returns, whereas Social Security is a pay-as-you-go system. She attributed the lack of reform to a general lack of political will among lawmakers.

One consequence of the wage growth formula is its reliance on workers contributing through their paychecks. Boccia pointed out that the number of workers has declined severely relative to the number of retirees collecting benefits, a trend driven by lower fertility rates. Biggs noted that Congress last made a significant effort to reform the program in the early 1980s. At that time, lawmakers were forced to raise taxes and increase the retirement age to address a funding crisis with only months to spare.

Biggs predicted that Congress will face a similar situation by 2032 when the trust fund runs out. He stated that lawmakers will be forced to take action not because they want to, but because they will have no choice. Johnson declared that the problem cannot be fixed in the time remaining due to decades of inaction. He suggested that the solution involves repealing a possible benefits reduction before the trust fund reaches insolvency in just under seven years.

Biggs, who was part of the George W. Bush administration's reform efforts, said that if Congress had acted 25 years ago, the fixes would have been barely noticeable. He argued that there is no easy fix today because lawmakers have consistently ducked the issue for political reasons. Boccia disagreed with Johnson's proposed solution and contended that the real answer is raising taxes. She noted that Congress would likely avoid benefit cuts due to their political toxicity and suggested that the current funding gap is more than two times larger than it was in the 1980s.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Hot Newswatch in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Hot Newswatch in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.