Michigan Lawmakers Face $200 Million Budget Gap in River Cleanup Efforts
State agencies struggle to manage 330,000 failing septic systems and enforce farm regulations amid a 75 percent fecal pollution rate.
By Amit Chukwu ·

Roughly 75 percent of Michigan rivers and streams contain fecal pollution levels that exceed state limits designed to protect swimmers and anglers. The state government currently allocates $200 million in non-federal dollars annually to water infrastructure, a sum that represents a small fraction of the $5 billion budget dedicated to roads. This funding disparity has left cities struggling to repair aging combined sewer systems that overflow during rainfall events.
The lack of financial resources compounds regulatory gaps. Michigan is the only state in the nation without a uniform statewide sanitary code for septic systems. Instead, the state relies on a patchwork of local regulations that advocates describe as inconsistent and loosely enforced. This regulatory vacuum allows an estimated 330,000 failing septic systems to discharge waste into waterways with minimal oversight. While bipartisan support exists for a statewide code that mandates periodic inspections, legislative bills have stalled due to disagreements over inspection timing and the costs of necessary repairs.
State enforcement capacity remains limited. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy employs more than 1,600 staff members. Only one of these employees is charged with full-time monitoring of the state’s rivers and streams for E. coli, a gut bacteria used to indicate fecal pollution. Staffing levels for enforcing manure pollution regulations at large livestock farms have remained largely unchanged for decades, even as the number of such farms has tripled. Currently, seven personnel are devoted at least part-time to ensuring compliance at these facilities.
Legislators are divided on the optimal path forward. Republican lawmakers have recently pushed to reduce the department’s staffing and cut its budget, arguing that the current regulatory approach is overly heavy-handed. In contrast, environmental advocates contend that limited staffing restricts the state’s ability to investigate pollution sources. Liz Kirkwood, strategic partnership officer at Flow Water Advocates, stated that the next governor should champion a statewide septic code. She noted, “Here you go. We’re the 50th state.”
Agricultural runoff remains the leading source of river pollution in the United States, according to the US Environmental Protection Agency. Michigan regulators and environmentalists argue that current permit terms for large livestock farms are too weak to prevent contamination. Farm groups have resisted efforts to strengthen these permits, describing the proposed changes as confusing and onerous. Eric Dennis, a research associate at the Citizens Research Council, said the state should rethink its regulatory approach rather than tweaking a permit system that applies to only a subset of farmers. He added, “We need to find a better way to do this.”
The state’s history offers precedent for recovery. In the 1960s, the Rouge River caught fire due to industrial pollution, and a stretch of the Clinton River could not support fish. In the 1950s, the odor of industrial waste in the Kalamazoo River prompted official action. In recent years, Michigan has successfully curbed pollution from phosphate-based detergents and industrial PFAS discharges. Robert Burns, who has served as the Detroit riverkeeper for more than 20 years, said, “Rivers are resilient…they just need a little bit of help.” He explained that if officials reduce the influx of pollution, the waterways will clean themselves over time.
Individual actions also contribute to the problem. Michigan is home to 2.4 million dogs, and experts say many owners do not pick up pet waste, allowing it to wash into waterways. Development that replaced wetlands and forests with grassy waterfront lawns has created ideal habitat for geese and ducks, facilitating runoff. Rachel Cuschieri-Murray, executive director of the Eaton Conservation District, emphasized the role of public education. She said, “I don’t know if people understand their personal relationship with the water or how connected they are to it.” Residents can reduce their impact by promptly cleaning up after pets, replacing turfgrass with native shrubs, and repairing malfunctioning septic systems or illicit sewer connections.
Lawmakers continue to debate funding mechanisms to close the infrastructure gap. A current bill proposes imposing a 25 cent-per-gallon royalty on bottled water companies to fund water initiatives. The state also faces pressure from cities that have been under decades-old orders to update combined sewers but have lacked the funds to finish the work. The federal government’s reduced contribution to water infrastructure upgrades has left Michigan’s aging core cities to absorb more of the cost, even as suburban flight and deindustrialization reduce their water system revenue.






