Wage cap misses 17% of earnings
AARP data indicates the payroll tax threshold now excludes a growing share of national income due to a shift toward capital gains.
By Grace Almasi ·

The Social Security wage base now captures only 83 percent of total national earnings, a figure that has fallen from 90 percent in previous decades. AARP attributes this decline to a structural shift in the American economy where income has moved from labor to capital over the last 40 years.
The program’s funding model relies on payroll taxes that were calibrated for an era when workers received a larger share of economic output. Rich Johnson of AARP stated that the economy has shifted from workers to capital, directing more money toward corporate profits and investment income rather than wages. Consequently, the payroll tax base generates less revenue relative to the total economy than it did when the system was designed.
The current wage cap is set at approximately $184,000. Johnson noted that this threshold was established when earnings were more evenly distributed among workers. Today, it leaves out about 17 percent of all earnings in the economy. This gap means a growing portion of high earners pays no Social Security payroll tax on the income above that limit.
Lawmakers in Congress are currently weighing options to address the funding shortfall and protect future benefits. Sen. Jeff Merkley of Oregon highlighted the program's importance, stating that for half of American seniors, Social Security accounts for between 50 and 100 percent of their income. Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin urged Congress to pass legislation that prevents benefit reductions and stops scaring seniors.
Advocates have proposed eliminating the wage cap to boost revenue or taxing corporate profits to supplement payroll taxes. These measures aim to align the funding structure with the current economic reality where capital income plays a larger role in national earnings.






